Exploring Structured Investment Products: A Comprehensive Guide

A visual representation of various structured investment products with distinct features.

Investment Understanding

Intro

Structured investment products can be a bit of a puzzle for many investors. They are unique financial instruments that blend various elements, differing from standard stocks and bonds. Understanding these products can mean distinguishing between suitable opportunities and potential pitfalls. In this section, we will dissect what structured products are, break down essential terms, and categorize the different types available in the market.

Key Terms Explained

To navigate through the world of structured investment products effectively, one must grasp some key terminology:

Structured Product: Typically, these are pre-packaged investments that combine traditional investment assets, such as stocks or bonds, with derivatives. The

Understanding Structured Investment Products

Structured investment products are a sophisticated tool in the financial world that offer investors tailored investment strategies combined with varying degrees of risk. In today’s complex financial landscape, grasping the essence of these products is paramount for both seasoned and novice investors. They serve as unique alternatives to traditional asset classes, unlocking potential avenues for enhanced returns while strategically addressing risk exposure.

Definition and Characteristics

A structured investment product is a pre-packaged investment strategy based on derivatives, primarily designed to meet specific financial goals. Unlike simple bonds or stocks, structured products often offer a payoff that depends on the performance of an underlying asset, index, or benchmark. These instruments blend equity, fixed income, and other complex derivatives to provide a customized return profile.

Key characteristics of structured products include:

Underlying Assets: The performance is closely tied to assets like stocks, commodities, or market indices.
Payoff Structure: The return can be fixed, contingent on market performance, or a combination of both.
Market Correlation: They provide an opportunity for diversification by linking investments to different market conditions.

In essence, structured investment products create a tailored path for investors, allowing them to align their financial objectives with market behavior.

Mechanics of Structured Products

Understanding how structured products operate requires knowledge of their mechanics. Simply put, these products are typically issued by financial institutions and are created using a combination of debt securities and derivative instruments. Here’s a brief breakdown:

Issuance: Financial institutions structure these products and sell them to investors, simultaneously managing any associated risks.
Payoff Scenarios: The returns often involve various scenarios; for instance, if the underlying asset performs well, the investor could earn significant returns, whereas poor performance might lead to minimal or no returns.
Maturity Date: Most structured products will have a definitive term, ranging from a few months to several years, after which the structured product matures.

These mechanics illustrate the potential complexity involved in structured products, making an understanding of their structure essential for investors who wish to navigate this investment landscape.

Comparison with Traditional Investments

When comparing structured investment products with traditional investments like stocks and bonds, several distinctions arise. Here are a few noteworthy comparisons:

Risk Profile: Traditional equity investments can lead to both dividends and capital appreciation directly tied to company performance. In contrast, structured products provide pre-defined risks and returns often with built-in protection against losses.
Customization: Structured products can be designed to meet specific investor needs and preferences. Traditional investments generally offer less flexibility.
Market Response: While traditional investments react directly to market dynamics, structured products can be more insulated, depending on their design, potentially offering stability in volatile markets.

"Investors should not overlook the unique structure of these products, as they might unearth opportunities missed by conventional market players."

Understanding the intricacies of structured investment products is not merely about knowing their definitions or mechanics; it's about recognizing how they fit within an investor's overall strategy. As you delve deeper into the world of these financial instruments, you’ll find they are instrumental in creating customized investment strategies that align with varying risk profiles and financial goals, standing in contrast to traditional investment avenues.

Types of Structured Investment Products

Understanding the multitude of structured investment products is vital for investors navigating today’s complex financial landscape. Each type carries its unique benefits and considerations, tailoring to the diverse strategies and goals numerous investors have in mind. By exploring these products, investors can make informed choices that align with their risk appetite, investment horizon, and financial objectives.

Equity-Linked Notes

Equity-linked notes are a hybrid investment vehicle designed to offer returns based on the performance of underlying equities, combining fixed-income characteristics with the upside potential of stocks. The distinguishing feature of equity-linked notes lies in their ability to deliver a minimum guaranteed return while allowing for upside participation in equity appreciation. Often, these notes will have a fixed tenure, generally ranging from one to five years, during which the investor's capital is tied up.

One key aspect is that they often have built-in protections against downside risk. For instance, if the underlying stock does not perform well, the structured product may still provide a return equal to the initial investment, unlike traditional equity investments which can lead to capital losses.

"Investors should note that while linked to equity performance, the final return heavily depends on the terms set at the issuance of the note."

Fixed Income Structures

Fixed income structures are specifically crafted to generate consistent income over time, combining traditional bonds with features that cater to specific investment needs. This category includes products like principal-protected notes, where the initial investment is guaranteed, and the returns are linked to the performance of a fixed asset or index, ensuring a degree of security that traditional equities cannot provide.

These structured products typically attract conservative investors seeking stable returns with a bias towards lower risk. The cash flows can be tailored, too, allowing investors options on when and how to receive payments, be it through regular interest payments or a lump sum at maturity. An essential element to monitor in fixed income structures is interest rate movements, as they can influence both the attractiveness and pricing of these products.

Market-Linked Notes

Market-linked notes are versatile instruments that provide returns based on the performance of various underlying market indicators, such as indices, commodities, or foreign currencies. This flexibility can capture different segments of the market, making it appealing for investors looking to diversify their portfolios.

Investors are often drawn to market-linked notes due to their potential for enhanced returns during favorable market conditions. However, they come with complexities related to how the returns are calculated. For example, if the underlying market index does well, the return might be capped, meaning while you can gain, your earnings could be limited. It’s crucial to understand the terms of these products, including the participation rate and any potential barriers.

Currency-Linked Products

Currency-linked products offer investors the chance to gain exposure to foreign exchange movements without outright purchasing the currencies themselves. These structured products can provide returns based on the performance of one or more currencies relative to another, often appealing to investors looking to hedge exposure or speculate on currency fluctuations.

Investing in currency-linked products also comes with inherent risks, particularly related to volatility in foreign exchange markets. Investors need to be aware of factors impacting currency movements, such as geopolitical developments, interest rates set by central banks, and economic data releases.

A thoughtful investor's approach will be essential, particularly when determining the relevance of currency movements to their broader investment strategy.

In summary, structured investment products, including equity-linked notes, fixed income structures, market-linked notes, and currency-linked products, each have their innovation and challenges. When understood thoroughly, these instruments allow investors to construct tailored portfolios that can meet their specific needs while navigating market volatility.

Benefits of Investing in Structured Products

Investing in structured products often feels like navigating through a labyrinth, with twists and turns that may not be immediately clear. Yet, the potential benefits can outweigh some of the complications inherent in these financial instruments. A deep dive into the nuances of structured products reveals a range of advantageous factors that can cater to diverse investment appetites and goals.

Tailored Investment Strategies

One of the foremost benefits of structured products is their ability to align with specific investment strategies. Unlike more traditional investment vehicles, these products can be customized to reflect individual risk tolerance and return expectations. Investors can leverage various underlying assets, including stocks, bonds, and commodities, to create tailored exposures.

For instance, an investor believing that a particular stock will perform well, but unsure when the rise will occur, could opt for a structured note linked to that stock's performance over a predefined period. This product can offer enhanced returns if the stock exceeds a specified price, all while limiting downside risk.

"A tool for tailoring investment features to fit specific market views can often serve as the missing piece in a diversified portfolio."

Potential for Enhanced Returns

Structured products have gained popularity partly due to their potential for enhanced returns compared to standard investments. The structured nature allows for the embedding of features like leverage and barriers that can amplify gains—if the market moves in the investor’s favor.

For example, consider a market-linked note tied to an equity index. If the index performs well, the structured product may offer returns that significantly outpace a simple investment in the same index. However, the catch here is that while the upside can be appealing, it's crucial to understand the specific terms and conditions, as they dictate how gains are realized.

Enhanced returns are often tied to conditions such as:

Barrier Thresholds - Exceeding specific performance levels.
Leverage Mechanisms - Amplifying returns through multiplier effects.
Payoff Structures - Offering better returns at predetermined price points.

Risk Mitigation Features

In an increasingly volatile market, risk mitigation becomes paramount, and structured products come equipped with features that can address investor concerns. They often include capital protection elements that safeguard investor principal to a degree. This element can be particularly attractive for those worried about the unpredictable swings in traditional markets.

For instance, a structured product may guarantee, at maturity, a certain percentage of the initial investment amount, depending on the performance of the underlying asset. A well-constructed product can insulate investors during tough economic climates while retaining the opportunity for gains under favorable circumstances.

In summary, structured investment products can.

provide customized investment strategies,
offer potential for elevated returns,
and have risk mitigation features to ease investor apprehensions.

These benefits present an enticing case for investors looking to navigate the intricate landscape of modern financial markets. However, understanding the inherent complexities and nuances is crucial for maximizing the potential of these unique financial instruments.

Risks Associated with Structured Investment Products

When it comes to structured investment products, understanding the risks is as crucial as knowing the potential rewards. These instruments are far from straightforward, and without a grasp of the associated risks, investors might find themselves in deep water. This section unpacks the different categories of risks, providing a thorough examination to aid investors in making informed decisions.

Market Risk

Market risk is a biggie in the world of structured products. Essentially, it refers to the potential for an investor to suffer losses due to fluctuations in market prices. For example, if an equity-linked note is based on a certain index or stock and that stock's value takes a nosedive, the investor's returns can be significantly impacted.

Investors need to appreciate that structured products often incorporate market movements into their returns. This means that the upside potential can be accompanied by substantial downside risks. Understanding the specific market conditions that a product is linked to, such as geopolitical events or economic data releases, is vital.

Credit Risk

Next on the list is credit risk. This aspect revolves around the possibility that the issuer of the structured product may default, failing to meet its financial obligations. In simple terms, if a company goes belly up, the products they issued can become worthless, leaving investors high and dry. The creditworthiness of the issuer is paramount when venturing into structured investments.

Investors should scrutinize credit ratings provided by agencies like Standard & Poor's and Moody's. A low credit rating can be a red flag, suggesting that the issuer might not be in a stable position. Thus, understanding where the issuer stands financially can make all the difference between a prudent investment and a potential loss.

Liquidity Risk

Moving on, we have liquidity risk, which is about how easy it is to buy or sell a structured product in the market. If an investor finds themselves in a tough spot and needs to sell a product, they may encounter hurdles if the market for that product isn’t robust. It could mean selling at a loss, which no one wants.

Considering the type of structured product and its market demand before investing is essential. Products that are newly issued might have limited buyers and sellers, making them more prone to liquidity issues. Always weigh how easily the investment can be liquidated when it comes time to cash out.

Complexity and Misunderstandings

Lastly, let’s talk about complexity and misunderstandings associated with structured products. These financial instruments can be intricate, often involving many different features, which can lead to confusion. Investors may misinterpret the mechanisms behind these products, leading them to believe they understand the risks when, in reality, they do not.

For instance, the presence of embedded options, like caps or collars, can alter how payouts are structured. An investor needs to grasp these nuances fully. Failing to do so may lead to misplaced expectations regarding returns, risk profiles, and overall performance. Thus, seeking clarity through educational resources and professional advice is always a good approach.

"Navigating the labyrinth of structured products requires a solid understanding of the risks involved, as overlooking even one can derail an otherwise promising investment journey."

In summary, while structured investment products can be potent tools for diversifying and enhancing return potential, they come with their own set of challenges. Being well-aware of market, credit, liquidity risks, and the intricacies involved is pivotal. Educating oneself and assessing personal risk tolerance can shield against unforeseen setbacks, ensuring a more balanced investment approach.

An infographic detailing the different types of structured investment strategies.

Evaluating Structured Products

Evaluating structured products is a critical step in the investment process, particularly for individuals or institutions looking to diversify their portfolio. These financial instruments might come with distinct features and risks that necessitate a careful analysis. It's not merely about picking the glitziest product off the shelf; understanding the nuances of performance metrics, issuer quality, and associated costs like fees and commissions can make or break an investment.

When determining the suitability of structured products, investors should focus on a few key elements:

Tailored Investment Goals: Each investor has different objectives. Some might aim for higher returns, while others prioritize capital preservation. Structured products can be designed to align with these goals.
Risk Assessment: Identifying risk factors associated with specific products is vital. Market fluctuations, credit reliability of issuers, and liquidity challenges all play significant roles. Without examining these variables, investors are navigating a minefield.
Cost Evaluation: The hidden costs in structured investments can eat into returns. Hence, it is wise to dissect all fees involved in the investment.

Adopting a methodical approach to evaluate structured products enables investors to make informed choices, enhancing their chances for favorable outcomes.

Performance Metrics to Consider

Performance metrics provide essential insights into how a structured product might behave under various market conditions. Understanding these metrics helps investors gauge potential returns, risks, and how these align with one’s financial aspirations. A few critical performance metrics to focus on include:

Historical Performance: While past performance is not always indicative of future results, it can serve as a benchmark. Assess how similar structured products have performed during various economic climates.
Cap and Participation Rates: Investors should examine the cap on returns and the participation rates offered. A high cap may seem alluring, but if the participation rate is low, actual gains can fall short of expectations.
Barrier Levels: These trigger conditions can affect returns drastically. Understanding how and when these barriers are hit can provide clarity on potential outcomes.

In essence, scrutinizing performance metrics enables investors to weigh the benefits and shortcomings of any given structured product thoroughly.

Credit Ratings and Issuer Quality

The quality of the issuer is pivotal in the landscape of structured products. A product backed by a reputable entity can mitigate various risks. Here’s why this aspect deserves keen attention:

Credit Ratings: Independent agencies evaluate issuer creditworthiness. Higher ratings often translate to lower risk of default. Reviewing agencies like Moody's or S&P Global can give investors clarity on the issuer's reliability.
Issuer Reputation and History: Beyond ratings, an issuer's background matters. A history of successful products and stability in the market can be telling signs of reliability.
Covenants and Guarantees: The terms set forth in covenants can provide additional layers of security. Knowing what guarantees accompany the product can help investors understand their safety net.

Be diligent in assessing an issuer's quality; it can mean the difference between a profitable investment and a detrimental loss.

Fees and Commissions

When dealing with structured products, understanding fees and commissions is akin to knowing how much sand is in your hourglass. These associated costs can significantly impact net returns, and they often lurk in the shadows. Here’s what to look out for:

Upfront Fees: Many products come with initial costs that can diminish your principal investment. Always check how much of your investment is going toward these fees.
Ongoing Maintenance Costs: Regular fees for managing structured products can accumulate over time. Understanding these is vital for an accurate long-term financial picture.
Hidden Commissions: Sometimes brokers earn commissions that aren't immediately apparent to the investor. Be proactive in asking about all potential costs.

"One person's fee is another person's worth; make sure you're capturing good value."

Ultimately, a meticulous examination of fees not only aids in selecting the best structured products but also maximizes returns on investment.

Case Studies on Structured Investment Products

When diving into the intricate world of structured investment products, case studies present valuable insights into their real-life applications. Understanding both triumphs and mistakes in the field enhances investors' comprehension. It's one thing to know theory, but seeing it in action lends heft to the concept of these financial instruments.

This section aims to provide a detailed examination of notable examples of structured products, both successful and less fortunate. Here, we will focus on how these products perform in practice and the takeaways they hold for investors.

Successful Structured Products

Successful structured products often exemplify how creativity and risk management can yield attractive returns. These products are designed not merely to compete with traditional investments, but to enhance them under specific market conditions. A notable instance is the equity-linked note issued by a prominent bank several years ago. This product offered a fixed coupon combined with a payoff linked to the performance of a technology sector index.

Performance: In a bull market, the note not only returned its promised coupon but also grew in value significantly because the sector performed exceptionally well. Investors who participated saw high returns while enjoying reduced downside risk, thanks to capital protection features baked into the structure.
Investor Perspective: Many investors felt a sense of .security knowing they could benefit from market upside without the typical risks associated with direct equity investments. This success story underscores the value of well-structured products that meet the goals of investors by allowing them to maximize returns while managing exposure.

Failures and Lessons Learned

On the flip side, the world of structured products is not without its dark chapters. A notorious example is the mortgage-backed securities that heavily contributed to the 2008 financial crisis. Initially marketed as safe investments with predictable returns, many of these products were far more complex than they appeared.

Complexity Issues: The intricacy of these structures led to widespread misconceptions about their true risk levels. Many investors, not grasping the underlying mechanisms, were blindsided when housing prices plummeted, causing substantial losses.
Key Lessons: This case demonstrates the vital importance of transparency and education. Investors must understand how structured products work in adverse conditions. A failure to account for market volatility and underlying asset performance can lead to fatal miscalculations.

"The devil is in the details"—such a mindset should accompany any discussion of structured investment products. Every investor must be equipped with the necessary knowledge and insights to navigate these tools effectively.

In summary, by examining these case studies, investors can gain practical insights. They reveal not only what makes a structured product successful but also cautionary tales that highlight the risks involved. And, unlike the common adage of "no risk, no reward," this segment presents the essence of evaluating structured products—where thorough understanding can very well be the difference between profit and loss.

Regulatory Considerations

Regulatory considerations play a crucial role in the landscape of structured investment products. Investors must understand the regulatory environment to make informed decisions about their investments. These considerations not only affect compliance and operational aspects of financial institutions but also ensure a level of protection for investors. In a world where financial markets can change on a dime, regulations provide a framework that can enhance investor confidence and promote market stability.

Global Regulatory Framework

The global regulatory framework for structured investment products involves multiple jurisdictions and can be quite complex. In many regions, financial authorities, such as the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), set guidelines that govern the marketing, selling, and reporting of these products. Each country may have its own set of rules, which complicates matters for international investors.

Some of the key components of this framework include:

Standardization of Product Offerings: Regulators often push for more standardized products, facilitating easier comparisons for investors.
Disclosure Requirements: Clear disclosure of risk factors, fees, and performance expectations helps investors understand what they are getting into.
Consumer Protection Laws: These laws safeguard investors against fraud and misrepresentation, fostering a fair marketplace.

Navigating this regulatory maze can be daunting, but it is essential for any investor looking to venture into structured products.

A graph comparing the performance metrics of selected structured investment products over time.

Impact on Investor Protection

Investor protection is at the heart of regulatory considerations. This aspect refers to the measures and guidelines established to shield investors from risks and malpractices in the market. A robust regulatory environment helps to level the playing field, ensuring that individual investors have an equal footing with institutional players.

The implications of regulatory practices on investor protection include:

Enforcement of Ethical Standards: Regulations enforce behaviors that discourage dishonest practices, ensuring that all stakeholders play by the rules.
Transparency in Structuring: Investors benefit from increased transparency in how structured investment products are created and marketed, reducing the likelihood of facing hidden risks.
Education Initiatives: Regulatory bodies often promote educational programs aimed at informing investors about the nature of structured products, their risks, and their potential benefits.

As regulatory bodies strengthen their oversight, investors can navigate financial landscapes with greater confidence.

Compliance and Disclosure Obligations

Compliance and disclosure obligations are fundamental components of regulation that dictate how financial institutions handle structured investment products. Financial firms must adhere to strict rules to provide transparent information that investors can rely on.

Importance of compliance and disclosure obligations includes:

Ensured Accountability: Companies are held accountable for their product offerings, which encourages ethical practices and truthfulness in marketing.
Information Accessibility: Required disclosures must be presented in accessible formats, allowing investors to make well-informed decisions without needing advanced financial expertise.
Risk Awareness: Clear communication about the risks associated with structured products helps investors to assess whether these products align with their financial goals and risk tolerances.

Suitability and Target Investor Profiles

Understanding the suitability of structured investment products is vital for both seasoned investors and newcomers. It forms the backbone of effective investing, ensuring that each financial product aligns perfectly with the investor's unique circumstances, aspirations, and risk tolerance. Investors aren’t just throwing darts at a board; they’re looking for returns that match their financial objectives.

Assessing Investor Goals

When diving into structured products, gauging investor goals is the first step. Are you saving for a child's education, planning for retirement, or merely looking to diversify your portfolio? Each goal has its own timeframe and risk profile. For instance, someone eyeing a house purchase in five years may prefer more stable, lower-risk products. Conversely, an investor eyeing retirement in twenty years might opt for more aggressive options to maximize returns.

Short-term Goals: Consider conservative structured notes that offer capital protection while providing modest returns. These could be suitable for those looking to preserve capital while still gaining a bit of interest.
Long-term Goals: Investors aiming for significant growth may lean towards equity-linked notes or market-linked products that provide higher potential returns despite their inherent risks.

It is essential to define your financial targets clearly, as this will dictate your choice of structured product.

Risk Appetite Considerations

Every investor comes with a different risk appetite. This can often be seen like being in a buffet line; each person has their own preferred choices based on taste and tolerance. Some might indulge in spicy options, while others stick to milder flavors. In investment terms, your risk tolerance can help determine the complexity of the structured products you choose.

Conservative Investors: Those with a lower risk tolerance may focus on capital-protected structured products, ensuring a steady yield without significant exposure to market fluctuations. Products like fixed income structures may be more appealing.
Aggressive Investors: On the contrary, investors willing to take on more risk could consider products that are linked to equity performance or other volatile assets, anticipating that potential higher returns justify the risk.

Identifying your risk appetite is a crucial exercise, as it greatly influences investment success.

Investment Horizon Assessment

Finally, the investment horizon is a key component to examine. It reflects how long you plan to hold an investment before cashing in your chips. Short, medium, and long-term horizons warrant different approaches in selecting structured investment products.

Short-term (1-3 years): Products that promise capital protection and fixed returns are typically favored. Liquid investments that mature within a few years are also commonly preferred, ensuring that funds are accessible when needed.
Medium-term (3-7 years): For those with a medium-term outlook, market-linked notes can be appealing. They provide a potential upside with manageable risks associated with fluctuations in the underlying assets.
Long-term (7+ years): Investors with a longer horizon can afford to take risks and ride out market volatilities. Here, they may consider equity-linked notes that allow for greater returns over time, even if they come with some bumps along the way.

Evaluating these elements together creates a framework that helps investors select structured products that are truly suitable for their profiles.

Ultimately, the right product must resonate with the investor's financial goals, risk appetite, and timeline. Balancing these aspects enhances the probability of achieving satisfactory investment outcomes.

As we navigate through structured investments, it’s critical to remain mindful of the complexities each product embodies. Awareness leads to better decisions, ultimately shaping one’s financial future.

Future of Structured Investment Products

The realm of structured investment products is on the brink of substantial evolution. As global markets shift, it’s crucial for both investors and financial professionals to stay abreast of the key developments affecting these financial instruments. Understanding the future of these products isn’t just about recognizing trends; it’s about being prepared for an ever-changing financial landscape. This section delves into the emerging trends, technological advances, and market shifts that are redefining structured investment products.

Emerging Trends and Innovations

As we move forward, the landscape of structured investment products is witnessing innovative strategies that reflect current economic sentiments and emerging market conditions. One significant trend is the increasing demand for personalized investment solutions. Investors today are not just looking for returns; they want products tailored to their risk tolerance and investment horizon. Financial institutions are responding by developing more customized structures.

Investors might encounter increasing combinations of traditional instruments with novel derivatives. For example, hybrid products that blend bonds with equity alternatives are surfacing, allowing greater flexibility in achieving specific investment outcomes. Furthermore, sustainable investing is carving out its niche, as a growing number of investors express interest in products that align with environmental, social, and governance (ESG) criteria. Such innovations promise not only higher returns but also ethically-aligned portfolios.

Technological Advances in Structuring Products

Technology is shaping the structured investment product landscape in ways previously unimagined. With the rise of fintech platforms, the accessibility of these products is improving at a rapid pace. Algorithms and artificial intelligence are now being utilized to create and manage complex investments, resulting in more efficient pricing models and risk assessments.

Moreover, blockchain technology is beginning to leave its mark. The ability to tokenize structured products can enhance liquidity and ease transactions, making them more attractive to investors. This innovation will likely reshape how investments are serialized and traded, streamlining the execution of trades and enhancing transparency.

Investors will benefit from reduced costs associated with management and administration of these products as technological efficiencies improve.

Potential Market Shifts

As demographics evolve and consumer preferences shift, market dynamics for structured investment products may undergo significant changes. An important aspect to consider is the rising generation of investors, primarily millennials and Gen Z, who are technologically savvy and expect seamless digital solutions. Their willingness to embrace new financial products might drive the demand for unique structured offerings that resonate with their values and priorities.

On a larger scale, economic shifts—such as those introduced by geopolitical events—could prompt a swing in how structured products are viewed. Investors must remain vigilant about these influences, as they can trigger shifts in demand and product design. The anticipated increase in interest rates, for instance, could lead to a surge in fixed-income structured products, as investors search for better yields.

Ultimately, as the market evolves, it’s essential for investors to stay informed and adaptable, ready to embrace the future of structured investment products with an educated mindset.

"Innovation is the only way to win." - Steve Jobs

Have More Awesome Articles:

Visual representation of traditional IRA vs. Roth IRA benefits